Once we’re speaking about AI picture mills, we are inclined to deal with the top end result – the great photos we get after only a few seconds. Nonetheless, we typically neglect in regards to the prompts that create them. They’re the unsung hero behind the scenes: those that energy creation by way of the right string of phrases.
Aside from the conversational nature of DALL-E 3, most AI picture mills observe a particular format: fragmented data, separated by commas or durations, about what you need a picture to turn out to be. So, if we have been to pit two AI picture mills in a head-to-head comparability, say Midjourney V6 and Adobe Firefly 2, how would they fare with the identical actual prompts?
That is what we’re discovering out on this article.
Variations Between Midjourney and Adobe Firefly Prompts
Earlier than V6, the important thing distinction between Midjourney and Firefly prompts is that the previous was much more fragmented and tokenized, whereas Firefly is a little more conversational. For instance, this was a immediate I used for V5 in comparison with how I would construction it with Firefly:
online game asset, sport map, giant lands and lakes, skyrim, cinematic, unreal engine, idea artwork
Adobe Firefly 2:
Online game asset, created by unreal engine, sport map with giant lands and lakes, within the model of skyrim, cinematic, idea artwork aesthetic
Now, with extra nuance, I’ve much more flexibility with Midjourney prompts. I can mess around with how I construction them since V6 is much more forgiving and versatile than V5.
One other distinction between these AI picture mills is the way you outline output parameters. Midjourney is much more complicated because it makes use of key phrases, whereas Adobe Firefly is extra streamlined with a settings block on the precise aspect of its editor. It is only a matter of choice, however the gist of it’s this: You are able to do much more with Midjourney, however Firefly offers you higher management and is extra user-friendly.
I would go so far as to say that Midjourney and Firefly are literally the 2 picture mills most related in prompting mechanics if we disregard output parameters. They use the identical key phrases (for instance, “within the model of”) and the identical delimiters (commas, durations).
Adobe Firefly 2 vs. Midjourney V6: 20 Prompts In contrast
There is not any higher means of exhibiting how Firefly and Midjourney react with prompts than by way of a comparability. So, listed below are 20 pairs of photos utilizing the similar, actual prompts.
Notice: All Midjourney V6 outputs are on the left, whereas the Adobe Firefly 2 photos are on the precise.
a groom carrying a lightweight grey swimsuit with a sage inexperienced tie and pocket sq., glamour road medium format pictures, portrait, pure lighting
full physique shot, a younger asian lady with a blonde shoulder-length haircut, free becoming sweatshirt, translucent layers, tender mist, dreamy ambiance, beige aesthetics, blue background, analog pictures, vogue
2020s trend, full physique of a 23-year-old japanese man sitting, minimalist and luxury trend, snapshot
a portrait pictures of a younger lady within the 1990’s, unsplash, 90s pictures, analog, model of petra collins
A Polaroid picture of a younger boy carrying a younger Golden Retriever with a date stamp within the backside white border of “June 16, 1989” in pink ink
When Firefly 2 generated the groom image, I puzzled if I used to be mistaken about this AI picture generator — that it was really able to producing real looking portrait photos. Seems, I am solely half-right. Firefly can create correct portraits provided that it has restricted supporting particulars. Aside from the primary set of photos, Midjourney is the clear-cut higher possibility.
The most important flaw of Firefly is that it skips over or misunderstands a number of the supporting particulars. As an alternative of producing a pocket sq., it created a flower. Firefly additionally didn’t generate an precise Polaroid picture as prompted however tried to simulate the look of a Polaroid picture by putting a sq. body round the primary topic of the picture.
As for the opposite photos, I nonetheless choose V6’s interpretations of the immediate. It is extra according to what I take into consideration, and it provides a novel aptitude to the ultimate output.
panorama pictures, northern lights in iceland, pastel night time sky, evoking a way of marvel, extensive angle shot
view from the highest of a mountain throughout a thunderstorm, with darkish and ominous clouds within the background, nikon pictures, panorama, timber furiously swaying, overcast, blue lighting
These are totally different interpretations of the identical immediate, and there is one thing to love about all of them. Nonetheless, there’s one thing that feels off in regards to the Firefly photos. For instance, the hills on the primary immediate look misplaced. I am additionally not a fan of getting daylight within the second immediate, because it cheapens the hazard of thunderstorms.
Product and Style Mockups
business pictures of a windbreaker with pastel 80s vaporwave aesthetic, lady, streetwear, trend, mamiya rb67
product pictures, craft beer, lovely lighting, classic aesthetics, earthcore, ultra-detailed, atmospheric
These are each good entries, however I nonetheless choose Midjourney’s output. If we’re speaking about adherence to the immediate, they each carried out properly, however Midjourney’s improved creativity simply places it above and past Adobe Firefly for now.
a person in a swimsuit taking a look at an ominous big inexperienced moon, darkish background, impressed by pink floyd, album artwork aesthetics, linocut print
an illustration of a lady in awe, impressed by stop-motion animation, up to date fairy story, magical realism, gelatinous varieties, easy minimalism
a lazy sunday afternoon, andrew tomine, pastel colours, outlined outlines, consolation and heat, residence aesthetics
artwork by Studio Ghibli, a surreal scene of a seaside with bioluminescent jellyfish within the sky, night time, psychedelia, minimalism, fluorescence, vibrant colours
a person with blue eyes trying on the sky, view from above his face, risograph, anime portray
a manga sketch of a younger lady with a melancholic expression, chiaroscuro, pale yellow background, outlined outlines
The one output right here that is comparatively shut in high quality are the jellyfish artworks. Moreover that, Firefly’s photos are too one word. Even in art work, they nonetheless have that look of inventory photos, full with large spherical eyes and a mode that resembles youngsters’s books. The one that did not have an individual as its topic (lazy sunday afternoon) fully disregarded the “residence” a part of the immediate and wasn’t generated logically.
witch crafting sport emblem, witch, magical spells, dagger, easy, minimalistic, spherical, within the model of Paul Rand
a easy vector emblem of a white tulip, impressed by van gogh work, minimalist
a clear emblem, avocado, postmodern, massimo vignelli, vivid colours
It is one factor to ignore a supporting element, however to fully miss the primary level of a immediate would not bode properly for Midjourney. In these three units of photos, solely the primary one from Firefly passes as a emblem. The opposite ones look extra like a whole art work, particularly the tulip.
Excessive Context Prompts (2)
A sensible previous wizard conjuring a glowing spell with historic runes swirling round his fingers. He has lengthy gray hair and beard and wears purple robes coated in arcane symbols. Shadows dance round him as magic flows from his fingertips. His wrinkled face is etched with focus whereas casts the paranormal incantation. He is on prime of a tower. Within the model of classic darkish fantasy illustration and lithography.
minimalism and surreal illustration, Nick Veasey, extraordinarily close-up shot, panorama of the cliffs of moher, mild tracing, glare lighting, linocut print, minimalism, line artwork, curve linked easily, dry brushing model‚ impasto, fluorescent coloration, colourful tones, ripples of coloration diffusing, marker coloring, printmaking model, layered curve, fujicolor superia X-TRA
After I created these photos, I purposefully created two sorts of high-context prompts: one which’s conversational and one which’s tokenized with numerous variables to think about. Each these photos carried out properly with the previous, though Firefly wasn’t capable of create it within the model of darkish fantasy or lithography illustration.
Alternatively, the distinction within the tokenized lengthy immediate is extra stark. Firefly ignored greater than half of the supporting context.
If we’re speaking solely about creativity, Midjourney V6 is miles forward of Firefly 2. There are a lot of causes that contribute to this, together with the primary aim of the corporate behind them, with Adobe spreading their manpower over a number of merchandise and Midjourney solely having their AI picture generator as their sole focus.
Nonetheless, there’s nonetheless so much to love with Firefly 2. For one, it is fully free. It additionally helps direct integration with different Adobe merchandise, which makes inpainting potential with Photoshop, InDesign, and extra.
As for nuance and immediate understanding, Firefly and Midjourney are surprisingly shut with shorter prompts, however the former cannot deal with high-context ones with out lacking some key data.
So, which might I like to recommend? When you have the cash, go for Midjourney. That stated, Firefly 2 is a rattling good free various.
In case you’re keen on figuring out extra about Midjourney and Firefly, I extremely suggest studying our different comparability articles. Have enjoyable!