Buried within the sea of different thrilling AI information like Sora and GPT-4o is the discharge of Adobe Firefly 3 in late April. This new and improved mannequin from Adobe Firefly 3 provides extra options to its already spectacular repertoire together with guarantees of higher nuance and creativity.
Right here’s the factor about me: I’ve this compulsive want to place AI fashions to the take a look at by evaluating them to the preferred fashions in its phase. So, for Adobe Firefly 3, that may be Midjourney.
On this article, I’ll be going by Adobe Firefly 3 and Midjourney together with their options, output high quality, and reply why Adobe received’t overtake Midjourney anytime quickly.
What are Adobe Firefly 3 and Midjourney?
Adobe Firefly 3 and Midjourney are each AI picture technology fashions, however they exist for utterly completely different causes. Beginning with the previous, Adobe Firefly is a mannequin created to coexist alongside different apps within the Adobe suite similar to Photoshop, InDesign, and Illustrator.
The third model of this mannequin was launched in late April 2024. I’d classify its outputs as “inventory picture”-like as a result of it’s made as an aiding device for designers.
Alternatively, Midjourney sits atop the AI picture technology house on account of its creativity and recognition. Whereas Firefly exists to assist designers, Midjourney is made to check the bounds of what AI can create. This platform has greater than 15 million concurrent customers worldwide and is presently on its sixth iteration. You may catch our full assessment of Midjourney’s newest mannequin right here.
Adobe Firefly 3 vs. Midjourney: Options
So far as AI picture turbines go, these two have essentially the most options. Let’s listing them one-by-one, beginning with the options that they share:
- Output Management. Lets you change between producing paintings or photographs.
- Side Ratio. Controls the facet ratio of the output.
- Fashion Energy. Impacts how the supporting info of your immediate impacts the general look.
- Fashion Reference. Helps you to enter a picture as a mode information.
- Generative Develop. Makes the canvas of the unique picture greater by producing additional particulars to fill within the blanks.
Two of the largest options that Adobe Firefly 3 has that Midjourney doesn’t are integration to different Adobe merchandise and structural reference, which lets you add a picture that may function a structural blueprint for the generated picture.
That stated, Midjourney has tons extra to supply than Adobe Firefly 3. Probably the most vital ones embrace a personality reference characteristic that lets you use photographs so the succeeding output can copy its topic, mixing of two photographs, image-to-prompt conversion, and picture variation power.
There’s additionally a distinction in how these two fashions implement their options. Whereas Adobe Firefly 3 has accessible buttons for personalisation, Midjourney depends extra on the way you construction your immediate for higher management. This implies the previous is much more user-friendly, whereas the latter is extra versatile.
Adobe Firefly 3 vs. Midjourney: Output High quality
Lifelike {Photograph}
Immediate: candid pictures, movie pictures, medium shot of a small lady enjoying with bubbles
Product Images
Immediate: industrial pictures, a glass of whiskey, industrial setting, sundown, excessive distinction, cinematic lighting, minimalist
Digital Artwork
Immediate: whimsical and fluid illustrations, dreamlike threads, dreamlike realism, abstraction, honeycore, gradients, impressed by graphic design, minimalist, pastel aesthetic
Character Design
Immediate: a knight in a darkish inexperienced armor getting into a darkish forest, 32-bit recreation, character design, darkish fantasy, gloomy environment
Structure
Immediate: architectural interpretation of open areas inside, a verdant yard, minimalist inside design, gentle brown and lightweight amber, movie pictures
With Textual content Technology
Immediate: a trainer writing the phrase “PYTHAGOREAN THEOREM” on a chalkboard
Ideas?
I really thought Adobe Firefly 3 held its floor on this comparability, but it surely’s nonetheless no match for Midjourney. The primary set of photographs had been the closest they ever had been. And but I’m nonetheless studying in direction of Midjourney’s output due to the simplicity and the addition of B&W results to observe the “movie pictures” facet of the immediate.
As for the others, it’s clear that Adobe Firefly 3 is a step in direction of the correct path, but it surely nonetheless lacks the creativity and nuance of Midjourney. Its output for digital artwork is just a little run-of-the-mill and I’m not an enormous fan of the character design paintings.
One factor that I’ve seen with Adobe Firefly 3 is the dearth of its structural coherence. For instance, of their product pictures picture, the glass has a small bulge in its left which isn’t current on the opposite facet. There are additionally components of their structure output that’s out of the norm, such because the footstool being on high of one other chair and the couch on the correct being inconceivable in actual life.
All in all, effort for Adobe Firefly 3 — but it surely nonetheless has an extended option to go earlier than it approaches Midjourney’s consistency and creativity.
The Backside Line
Let’s return to the query posed on the very high of this text: does Adobe have what it takes to edge out Midjourney?
My reply is straightforward: it doesn’t, and I’m undecided it ever will.
The actual fact of the matter is that these are two utterly completely different platforms. After all, Adobe Firefly 3 will all the time have photographs that look stock-like as a result of that’s what it’s for. Alternatively, Midjourney will all the time have extra inventive photographs as a result of it’s meant to totally discover the place AI artwork may go.
On the finish of the day, these AI fashions can coexist as a result of they’ve utterly completely different demographics. The one factor that issues is how they each carry out of their respective lanes.
Wish to be taught extra about AI artwork? You may learn our greatest comparability thus far right here. Have enjoyable!
